UPDATE: In a thrilling finish to the PSAL 4A city championship, Tottenville fell 34-27 to Erasmus Hall at Midwood High School on December 3, 2023. Star running back Tyshawn Bent ignited the game with a spectacular opening kickoff return for a touchdown, raising hopes for the Pirates to secure their first city title in 22 years.
However, Erasmus Hall, a perennial powerhouse, quickly regained momentum. The Dutchmen’s trio of stars—quarterback Kendu Brown, running back Ameir Morrow, and wide receiver Justus Murray—spearheaded a comeback that would seal Tottenville’s fate. Despite a valiant effort, Tottenville’s season concluded with a remarkable record of 12-1.
The defeat marked a bittersweet end for Tottenville, who had fought hard all season and only suffered one loss. Erasmus Hall improved to 10-2, avenging their earlier defeat to Tottenville, which had been a tightly contested 38-35 game in September.
This championship win is significant for Erasmus Hall as it clinches the program’s seventh city title, pushing them ahead of Susan Wagner’s six titles and just one shy of Curtis’ record of eight. The victory not only solidifies Erasmus Hall’s status as a top contender in high school football but also reflects the intense rivalry within the PSAL.
Fans and players alike felt the emotional weight of this championship game, with many discussing the potential for Tottenville to reclaim glory in the future. The Pirates demonstrated resilience and skill throughout the season, and this game showcased their determination to succeed.
As the dust settles on this year’s championship, all eyes will be on both teams as they prepare for next season. Tottenville’s head coach Brian Neville expressed pride in his team’s achievements and the spirit they displayed throughout the season.
The victory for Erasmus Hall not only marks a significant milestone for their program but also sets the stage for an exciting future in PSAL football. Fans can expect to see both teams battling it out again as they strive for the title next year.
Stay tuned for more updates and reactions from this monumental game.
