Each year, the race for the Academy Awards’ Best Picture generates intense discussion and debate among film enthusiasts. While some winners are celebrated, others spark controversy regarding their selection. A recent analysis by Watch With Us revisits the last 97 winners, highlighting five films that arguably deserved the Oscar more than the actual recipients.
‘The Sixth Sense’ Over ‘American Beauty’ (1999)
In a year dominated by strong contenders, the Academy awarded the Best Picture Oscar to American Beauty, a film that has not aged gracefully. Critics have often labeled Sam Mendes’ exploration of suburban malaise as superficial. In contrast, The Sixth Sense, directed by M. Night Shyamalan, emerged as a groundbreaking horror film. With remarkable performances from Haley Joel Osment and Toni Collette, the film not only captivated audiences, breaking box office records but also delivered a poignant narrative that resonates even today.
‘E.T.’ Over ‘Gandhi’ (1982)
The choice of Gandhi for Best Picture in 1983 raised eyebrows, especially when considering the impact of E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial. Directed by Steven Spielberg, this film captured the hearts of audiences worldwide, including critics like Pauline Kael, who praised its magical storytelling. While Gandhi attempted to tackle significant historical themes, its lengthy runtime and dry pacing failed to engage viewers as effectively as the beloved tale of a young boy befriending an alien. The Academy missed an opportunity to honor a film that truly resonated with the public.
‘The Shawshank Redemption’ Over ‘Forrest Gump’ (1994)
The Academy’s choice of Forrest Gump as the 1995 Best Picture winner is often scrutinized in light of other nominees from that year. While Forrest Gump was a box office success, its cultural relevance has diminished over time. In contrast, The Shawshank Redemption, directed by Frank Darabont, has garnered a devoted following and consistently ranks as one of the greatest films of all time. The film’s exploration of friendship and hope within the confines of prison remains compelling, showcasing the enduring power of storytelling.
‘Any Nominee’ Over ‘The Shape of Water’ (2017)
In 2018, the Academy awarded The Shape of Water the coveted Best Picture Oscar, a decision that has drawn mixed reactions. While the film, directed by Guillermo del Toro, received acclaim, 2017 was notable for its stellar pool of nominees. Films such as Get Out, Dunkirk, and Call Me by Your Name presented strong arguments for the award. These films not only showcased exceptional storytelling but also addressed profound themes, making a compelling case for recognition over The Shape of Water, which some viewed as overshadowed by its competition.
‘2001: A Space Odyssey’ Over ‘Oliver!’ (1968)
One of the most intriguing omissions in Oscar history is 2001: A Space Odyssey, directed by Stanley Kubrick. Although not nominated for Best Picture in 1969, its innovative approach to filmmaking deserves recognition. The film redefined the science fiction genre, offering a unique sensory experience that surpassed the conventional narrative structure. In contrast, Oliver!, a well-crafted musical, failed to match the groundbreaking impact of Kubrick’s masterpiece. The Academy’s choice to overlook such a pivotal film raises questions about the criteria for awarding the top honor.
The discussion surrounding the Best Picture winners continues to evolve, with audiences reflecting on the merits of past selections. As the Academy Awards approach each year, the debate over what constitutes the “best” film remains as lively as ever.
