The New Hampshire Supreme Court welcomes a new justice following a decisive vote from the Executive Council. On October 25, 2023, the council confirmed Judge Dan Will with a vote of 4-1. This appointment comes amid some controversy related to Will’s prior role as New Hampshire Solicitor General, where he defended various emergency orders during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Background of the Nomination
Judge Will’s nomination received notable bipartisan support despite some opposition from conservative members of the council. Councilor Dave Wheeler, the sole dissenting voice, expressed his concerns regarding Will’s prior work related to pandemic measures. Wheeler stated that this experience raised questions about Will’s approach to judicial independence.
In contrast, supporters highlighted Will’s qualifications and character. Executive Councilor Karen Liot Hill spoke highly of him, noting, “Again and again, I heard from attorneys and colleagues who spoke not only of his exceptional intellect but also of his humility.” This sentiment reflects the broader support Will garnered throughout the nomination process.
Implications of the Appointment
Judge Will’s confirmation marks a significant addition to the New Hampshire Supreme Court, which plays a crucial role in interpreting state laws and addressing legal challenges. His experience as Solicitor General may provide valuable insights as the court navigates complex legal matters, particularly those stemming from the pandemic.
The decision to appoint Will highlights ongoing dialogues within New Hampshire regarding the balance between public health measures and individual rights, an issue that has evoked strong feelings across the political spectrum. His judicial philosophy and decisions will likely be closely monitored by both supporters and critics as he begins his tenure.
Overall, Judge Will’s confirmation is seen as a pivotal moment for the New Hampshire Supreme Court, setting the stage for future legal interpretations and decisions that could impact residents statewide.
