The future of general manager Joe Schoen with the New York Giants appears to be in flux, despite recent assurances from team ownership. Following the dismissal of head coach Brian Daboll, reports emerged suggesting that Schoen’s position is not guaranteed as the team approaches the winter months. While there are indications of uncertainty, internal sources have communicated that Schoen is likely to remain in his role for now.
According to Jordan Raanan of ESPN, Schoen’s contract is in effect through 2026, and multiple league insiders believe he will stay unless a compelling head coaching candidate insists on bringing in a new general manager. This scenario seems unlikely, as Schoen is currently leading the search for Daboll’s replacement and compiling a list of potential candidates.
Giants co-owners John Mara and Steve Tisch have publicly stated that Schoen will take the lead in finding a new head coach. However, his track record has raised concerns, particularly regarding several high-profile draft misses during his tenure. Notably, rookie pass-rusher Abdul Carter, a first-round pick in 2025, was recently benched after missing a walk-through session. Since the start of the 2023 season, the Giants have struggled, recording a dismal 11-34 win-loss record under Schoen’s management.
Despite these challenges, interest in the Giants’ head coaching position remains strong. Raanan reports that one source familiar with the situation described the job as “highly coveted.” This perception is largely due to the team’s “young core” of talent, which includes rookie quarterback Jaxson Dart, injured wide receiver Malik Nabers, left tackle Andrew Thomas, and injured rookie running back Cam Skattebo.
A senior executive who spoke with Jourdan Rodrigue of The Athletic raised concerns about the implications of hiring a new head coach while retaining Schoen. The executive noted, “A red flag, to me, when an organization just fires a coach is that they’re not being introspective enough about the shortcomings around the coach.” This comment underscores the belief that issues within the organization extend beyond the coaching staff and may involve higher levels of management.
As the Giants prepare for their upcoming game against the Detroit Lions on Sunday, the team stands as 10-point underdogs, according to ESPN BET. Should the performance in this game fall short of expectations, speculation regarding Schoen’s future could intensify.
In this complex landscape, Schoen’s ability to navigate the challenges ahead will be closely scrutinized, as fans and analysts alike watch for any signs of change within the organization.
